2024 Compact SUV Face-Off: Honda CR-V vs Toyota RAV4 vs Nissan Rogue

If you’re shopping for a compact SUV in Metro Vancouver, these three names show up again and again: Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, and Nissan Rogue. They’re popular for the same reasons—easy to park, great for commuting, and versatile enough for Costco runs, ski trips, and family life.

But “popular” doesn’t mean “the same.” Here’s a practical comparison (with the numbers that matter), plus how to choose smart when buying used.

Quick spec snapshot (the stuff buyers actually ask about)

Cargo space (behind the rear seats):

• CR-V: about 39.3 cu ft Honda Automobiles+1
• RAV4: about 37.5 cu ft Edmunds+1
• Rogue: about 31.6 cu ft Edmunds

Fuel economy (EPA examples):

• RAV4 (gas, FWD trims): up to 27 city / 35 hwy / 30 combined mpg toyota.com+1
• Rogue (FWD): 33 combined mpg (30/37 city/hwy) on FuelEconomy.gov listings fueleconomy.gov
• CR-V (non-hybrid, FWD): 28 city / 34 hwy noted by Car and Driver Car and Driver

Reality check: exact mpg varies by drivetrain (FWD/AWD), trim, tires, and weather. Use these as “directional truth,” not a promise.

Honda CR-V (2024): the “do-everything” comfort pick

Why people love it:

• Excellent day-to-day comfort and visibility, and it’s easy to drive in city traffic.
• Cargo space is class-leading in this trio, which matters if you’re hauling strollers, hockey gear, or delivery boxes. Honda Automobiles+1

Who it fits best:

• Families who care about cabin space and a calm driving feel.
• Buyers who want a balanced SUV that doesn’t feel “busy” or harsh on Vancouver roads.

Used-buyer tip:
When test driving, do a quick “real life” check: open the liftgate, load a suitcase or two, fold the rear seats, and see if the layout matches your lifestyle. The CR-V usually wins here on sheer usability. Honda Automobiles

Toyota RAV4 (2024): the proven “value + reliability” crowd favorite

Why people love it:

• The RAV4 has a long-standing reputation for strong resale and broad owner confidence, which is why it stays in high demand in the used market.
• Solid fuel economy in common gas trims, and lots of trim variety. toyota.com+1

Who it fits best:

• Buyers who prioritize long-term ownership and resale value.
• Anyone who wants a “safe bet” compact SUV with widespread parts/service familiarity.

Used-buyer tip:
Because demand is high, the best RAV4s sell fast. If you’re shopping used, move quickly on vehicles with clean history, complete service records, and no accident flags.

Nissan Rogue (2024): the efficiency-focused techy option

Why people love it:

• Rogue stands out in EPA fuel economy, especially in FWD form—FuelEconomy.gov lists 33 mpg combined (30/37) for some 2024 Rogue FWD variants. fueleconomy.gov
• Strong suite of driver-assist and comfort features depending on trim.

Who it fits best:

• Commuters doing lots of Highway 99 / Oak / Knight / Alex Fraser type driving.
• Buyers who want a modern feel and strong mpg numbers.

Used-buyer tip:
Cargo volume behind the second row is smaller than the CR-V and RAV4 in many spec listings, so if you haul bulky items, measure your must-fit items (e.g., stroller width) before you fall in love. Edmunds

Which one should you choose?

Pick based on your real use case, not internet arguments:

• Choose CR-V if you want the most practical space and a smooth everyday drive. Honda Automobiles+1
• Choose RAV4 if you want a proven, steady long-term ownership play with strong demand in the used market. toyota.com+1
• Choose Rogue if fuel economy and a tech-forward commuting vibe are top priorities. fueleconomy.gov

Buying used in Metro Vancouver: 5 quick checks that matter

1. Tires + alignment: Vancouver rain + worn tires is a bad combo.
2. Brake condition: lots of stop-and-go driving wears brakes faster than people expect.
3. Service records: even basic records help you avoid expensive surprises.
4. Accident history: ask for documentation and inspect panel gaps/paint match.
5. Trim/drivetrain fit: AWD is nice for mountain trips; FWD can be the better value if you’re mostly city/highway.

Why Trust Auto is a smart place to shop

At Trust Auto, we work with buyers every day across Richmond, Surrey, and the wider Metro Vancouver area—and we’re recognized as one of the largest used car dealerships in the region, with lots of SUV inventory moving through the lot. That matters because it gives you real choice: different trims, mileages, and price points, so you can compare CR-V vs RAV4 vs Rogue side by side instead of guessing from photos.

If you tell us your budget, driving habits, and “must-have” features, we’ll help you narrow it down quickly—and avoid overpaying for options you don’t actually need.

Hashtags (crawler-friendly)

#CompactSUV #UsedSUV #HondaCRV #ToyotaRAV4 #NissanRogue #SUVComparison #UsedCars #VancouverUsedCars #RichmondBC #SurreyBC #MetroVancouver #FamilySUV #FuelEconomy #CargoSpace #CarBuyingTips #TrustAuto